CMR vs SMR hard drives
For a NAS that runs ZFS or works hard, choose a CMR drive: Western Digital says its CMR WD Red Plus and Red Pro should be used with ZFS, and points its SMR WD Red at lighter home and small-office use. SMR overlaps the recording tracks to fit more on each platter, and the family name does not tell you which you get: Seagate lists its 3.5-inch BarraCuda 4TB as SMR and its 12TB as CMR.
CMR and SMR drives, priced
The cheapest new internal drive of each size listed with both methods, so the price of choosing CMR is one look away. From 8 TB up, every drive in our latest check that we can label records with CMR; the cheapest per TB there is Seagate IronWolf 12TB NAS Hard Drive 7200 RPM (12 TB, 3.5-inch), $449.99 ($37.50/TB).
| Size | CMR | SMR |
|---|---|---|
| 1 TB | Seagate Exos 7E8 1TB Internal Hard Drive Enterprise (3.5-inch), $90.00 | Seagate BarraCuda ST1000DM014 1 TB Hard Drive (3.5-inch), $159.00 |
| 2 TB | Seagate IronWolf 2TB NAS Internal Hard Drive HDD (3.5-inch), $128.60 | Seagate 2TB BarraCuda SATA 6Gb/s 128MB Cache 2.5-Inch, $214.10 |
| 4 TB | Seagate SkyHawk ST4000VX016 4TB 5400 RPM 256MB Cache (3.5-inch), $179.99 | Seagate Barracuda ST4000DM004 Internal Hard Drive 4TB (3.5-inch), $175.99 |
| 6 TB | Seagate SkyHawk 6TB Surveillance Hard Drive 256MB Cache (3.5-inch), $275.00 | WD Red 6TB NAS Internal Hard Drive (3.5-inch), $444.45 |
Use the manufacturer's model list
Seagate publishes recording technology by product family and capacity. Its IronWolf and IronWolf Pro rows are listed under CMR, while Exos includes different recording technologies. A broad family name is therefore not a safe substitute for an exact model check.
For a NAS, check enclosure support
Match the drive model and interface to the enclosure's supported-drive list. The price page can compare capacity and cost, but a retailer title does not establish enclosure support or sustained write behaviour.
Compare price after the technology check
Use price per TB within the acceptable models and conditions. For a multi-drive array, compare usable capacity after mirroring or parity rather than adding the labels on the boxes.
Dated manufacturer and application information
Seagate. SMR overlaps recording tracks. Seagate lists recording technology by product family and capacity; IronWolf and IronWolf Pro are listed under CMR, while the Exos range includes different recording technologies.
Western Digital. Western Digital says its WD Red Plus and WD Red Pro drives record with CMR and recommends them for ZFS, where a rebuild leaves an SMR drive no idle time for its own housekeeping.
Western Digital. Western Digital's plain WD Red in 2TB to 6TB records with SMR, which the company describes as suited to lighter home and small-office NAS workloads.
Compare prices and specifications
NAS drive listingsChoose a NAS driveRAID capacity calculator